A tax group is a formal arrangement enabling two or more local companies to work as one for tax filing and compliance as defined under Article 40 of Corporate Tax, UAE. It provides the criteria for making a tax group in the corporate tax system to achieve greater control and interrelatedness of its members. The capital ownership needs are critical for the purposes of preserving and maintaining the integrity and consistency of the tax group under Corporate tax.
What Are the Key Ownership Requirements for Forming a Tax Group?
The following are the main prerequisites to form a Tax Group:
- Legal Entity Status:- For the formation of a tax group, a legal person status as applied to every member is an important requirement. This way, only those individuals recognized as a legal entity by the UAE law qualify. Natural persons or entities not so classified are outside. In practical terms, this implies that, on one side, are incorporated entities in the form of LLCs, PJSCs, trusts, and corporations, while unincorporated partnerships, civil companies, and establishments do not qualify.
- The Minimum Threshold in Terms of Ownership:- There is a definitive ‘tax’ group ownership which can be anywhere around 95% wherein the parent company must exercise considerable control over its subsidiary companies. The parent company is supposed to have not less than 95% share capital in each of them. This can be direct or indirect. Therefore, it can be concluded that the company possesses adequate financial control and interest over the subsidiary, and as such, there is a common incentive for coordination and integration within the group.
- Reserve in Ownership of Voting Shares:- In order for a company within the group to consider any voting process, there must be respect to the minimum percentage ownership of 95% in shares of sub-companies. These shares can be held on paper only. A necessary factor for this is that it determines control for the parent entity over the key issues regarding the subsidiary. In most cases, the shareholders have the vote beside the shares, but in this case, there are some limitations set, for instance, the limit on voting furnished may frustrate this position.
- Profits and Net Assets Entitlement:- The second main necessary claim is that at least 95% of the net profits and net assets of the subsidiaries must be claimed. This requirement is justified by stating the financial interest of the parent company and the subsidiary was well integrated. Net profits are profits made by the subsidiary in the given fiscal year. Net assets pertain to the assets owned by the subsidiary in a sell off scenario. The parent company is entitled to sufficient equity of the subsidiary to ensure that net profits are made and net value is retained.
- Non-Exempt Status:- In a tax group, every member must ensure that the parent company and all its subsidiaries Exempt Persons as contained in the UAE Corporate Tax Law, this will automatically disbar them. Commonly, Exempt Persons are certain government departments and free zone entities that conduct business with some exemptions. This ensures that all members of the tax group will be subjected to the same corporate tax policy therefore guaranteed equality and uniformity.
- Exclusion of Qualifying Free Zone Persons:- In this case, qualifying free zone persons who operate from exclusive tax regimes and privileges cannot use the benefits of being part of a tax group. Such persons operate with one model of taxation, like paying zero tax on qualifying income, and may not be amongst the other members of the tax group since they are expected to be charged according to general tax rules. That is why such persons must always be kept outsiders to the tax group and this to prevent losing the special tax value.
- Same Financial Year:- A tax group must ensure its tax group members’ financial activity reporting is done in an effective manner. In this way, the tax group must have the same operational financial year. This uniformity will ensure that the financial statements are consolidated on the same time scale for all the entities involved. This simplifies the financial analysis and decision-making process within the group.
- Uniform Accounting Standards:- This growing concern is to ensure that the uniform accounting standards are adhered to by tax group members which will ultimately lead to unchecked accuracy in the reporting of financial information. Adoption of uniform accounting standards avoids any relative inconsistency or disruption in the reporting of financial matters in addition to allowing the tax group to portray a consistent view of its financial affairs.
Consequences of Forming a Tax Group: A Parent and Subsidiary Company Overview
A Tax Group formation manifests in a unique set of obligations, advantages, and obstacles for the Parent Companies and their Subsidiaries alike. Failure to appreciate these issues could lead to improper tax compliance and planning at the group level. This guide addresses those issues, along with the benefits and risks that could accompany them.
Roles and Responsibilities within a Tax Group for the Parent Companies
The Parent Company is the one primarily tasked with the management of the Tax Group. Some of these include:
- Broadened Responsibilities:-The Parent Company will take all responsibility for the Tax Group’s tax compliance activities such as, but not limited to, consolidated filing, tax remittance, and tax records.
- Responsible Group Filing:-Consolidated tax returns lessen the burden within the group; however, it necessitates the proper synchronization of financial records.
Exposure Risks For Parent Company and Subsidiaries
The Parent Company is prone to financial losses when it assumes the liabilities of the subsidiaries and is liable for connivance by the subsidiary entities. This joint and several liability provision increases risk exposure for the company.
| Responsibility | Description | Potential Risk |
| Tax Compliance | Centralized under the Parent Company | Increased liability for non-compliance |
| Consolidated Tax Filing | Simplifies reporting for the group | Demands careful data management |
| Shared Liability | Accountability for Subsidiary actions | Higher financial exposure |
For Subsidiaries, joining a Tax Group calls for these companies to address operational interdependencies and assume collective responsibilities.
- Loss of Autonomy:-Subsidiaries must respect the directives of the Parent Company and thus lose control over their tax affairs. Added financial exposure is brought about by Shared Liability at the expense of the Tax Group.
- Loss of control and decision Shared responsibility brought even further by these subdivisions of the tax group means that the financial burden will in one way or the other be wreaked Stability at the Parent Company. Losing the privilege of making major decisions while being at the mercy of this Parent company has grave operational ramifications. These include having limited flexibility on how the business unit intends to operate.
Consequences Of Exiting a Tax Group
Entail a loss requiring detailed advance planning, and this means losing the power to control any taxation arms that have not been paid. For Subsidiaries, these include Expatriate and Immigrant Taxes.
| Impact on Subsidiaries | Description | Implications |
| Loss of Autonomy | Relieves central authority over one branch of the firm having been decided by the Parent taxation authority below the Parent | Reduced operational flexibility |
| Shared Liability | Means being in a joint enterprise increases business risks leading businesses to make unwise decisions. | Increased financial responsibility |
| Exit Process | Being free of the central authority overbearing and control does not come with free, there is some price to be paid, which requires comprehensive tax planning | Requires careful tax planning |
-
Formation of this tax group is not free from state Shares
As per Article 40 Clause 2 of Corporate Tax, the Tax Group is allowed to be created in case a Government Entity owns not less than 95 percent of the shares. Other requirements may exist as have been stipulated by the tax administration.
-
Formation and Dissolution
Approval of the tax authority is necessary for the formation of this Tax Group as well as for its dissolution. Dissolution can take place in circumstances where ownership or eligibility standards have not been fulfilled.
Tax Group Compliance Expectations
Once a Tax Group has been formed, there are several ongoing requirements that must be followed:
- Joint and Several Liability: Imposes a greater risk, while ensuring shared responsibility.
- Retain and Prepare all Exchequer Papers: Compliance with tax regulations must be followed with particular importance to accurate records.
- Subsidiary Changes: Changes to the addition or deletion of Subsidiaries must be done under organizational restrictions.
| Description of Compliance Requirements | Description |
| Single Taxable Entity | Only the Parent Company acts as a single member |
| Liability Sharing | Ensures that all parties will be held responsible |
| Record-Keeping | Full compliance in maintaining the guidelines of reporting |
| Subsidiary Adjustments | Tax authority’s approval is mandatory |
Simplified Submission Processes for the Tax Group Benefits
- Simplified Compliance:-Administrative burden among the group is reduced by virtue of consolidating tax filings.
- Optimized Tax Efficiency:-One entity’s losses may reduce the profits in another entity, thus reducing tax liability.
- Enhanced Financial Reporting:- Uniform accounting principles along with fiscal YEARS managed under the same Synchronization increases the clarity and comparability of financial statements.
| Benefit | Overview Description |
| Simplified Compliance | Complete documents consolidate administrative tasks and lessen burden |
| Tax Optimization | Group tax obligations are reduced through loss offsets |
| Financial Transparency | Improved understanding through set reporting standards |
Challenges and Risks
Establishing a Tax Group has its benefits, but there are hurdles as well:
- High Ownership Threshold
Most groups with dispersed ownership structures will not be included due to the 95% ownership requirement.
- Stringent Compliance Obligations
Consistency in reporting and filing requires significant forethought and management.
- Liability Concerns
Financial risk is increased for all entities within the group due to shared liability, which places greater emphasis on internal controls.
| Challenge | Summary Description | Impact |
| Ownership Threshold | Limits eligibility | High bar |
| Compliance Requirements | High degree of administrative effort | Increased management |
| Liability Risks | Heightened need for internal control | Heightened exposure |
Conclusion
When properly structured, forming a Tax Group can lead to reduced tax compliance costs and greater financial success. Parents Countries and Subsidiary Companies bearing greater liability will need to more accurately manage resources and adhere to controls, policies and plan ahead of time. The Economic legal framework governing the tax group formation will be followed in detail to the instructions of the tax authority.
FAQ: Key Ownership Requirements for Forming a Tax Group
- Who can be the part of a Tax Group?
Only incorporated entities such as LLCs, PJSCs, corporations, and trusts qualify. Unincorporated entities, such as partnerships or civil companies, do not.
- What is the minimum ownership requirement for a Tax Group?
The minimum 95% of subsidiaries must be owned by the parent company either directly or indirectly.
- Is there a minimum percentage of voting shares required?
Yes, the parent must have at least 95% of the voting shares in subsidiaries to retain control.
- What percentage of profits and assets must the parent company control?
The parent must be able to claim at least 95% of the subsidiary's net profits and assets.
- Whether exempt companies can join a Tax Group?
No, all group members must not be exempt entities (e.g., government departments, free-zone companies).
- Can free zone companies join a Tax Group?
No, free zone companies with special tax privileges cannot be part of the tax group.
- Do all group members need the same financial year?
Yes, all members must have the same financial year for consistent reporting.
- Are uniform accounting standards required for the group?
Yes, consistent accounting standards must be followed for accurate financial reporting
Shayan Khan is an experienced Corporate Tax Consultant with over 4 years of expertise. He’s skilled in negotiating and investigating taxes with government bodies like the Federal Tax Authority. Shayan is really good at reviewing and drafting tax papers and offers strategic advice on complex tax matters. Clients trust his guidance in navigating tax procedures and minimizing liabilities.
